Will the Downward Trend in the Economy Impact Hunting?
Yeah, the title sucks. Sorry…
But here’s the deal. In comments to my recent post about Washington state’s position on lead ammo, the conversation diverged into some speculation by Holly (the NorCal Cazadora) about whether more people would start hunting as a result of the economic downturn. She wrote:
Another blogger out there just asked recently if others are seeing evidence that the poor economy is driving licenses and hunting UP because of people’s desire to fill their freezers.
Michael Riddle, from NativeHunt, replied that he doubted that a person could, legally, subsist on wild game. I would disagree with that from a theoretical perspective… but only at that academic level. It would be quite possible, especially if you factor in wild hogs (year-round, no limit, etc.) to gather enough game, fish, and fowl. The catch is, it would cost a small fortune and require a huge investment in time and effort.
Which brings his final point to light:
The drop in hunter numbers only coincides with correlating numbers of people simply tightening up their belts during a rough economic turmoil and they have cut out extraneous activities.
When the economy picks up we will see those numbers pick up and increase alongside of our paycheck increases.
I agree with Michael that the reality is that the economic situation is much more likely to drive people away from hunting than into it. It’s not a necessity for anyone in this country, and if things really get tight, most folks aren’t going to spend the money for a 5% chance at killing a deer (much less two deer), or drop $20 a pop for a tag, then spend $400 or more to go shoot a hog on private land (forget about public land hunting.. the cost to success ratio is ridiculously low there).
Point being, hunting for meat is not an economical alternative to buying it from the store… at least not if you’re doing it legally. Sure, there may be the exception here and there, but generally speaking, it doesn’t make any sense
What you will likely see, if things get really-really bad, is a slight uptick in poaching, just like they saw during the depression.
Keep in mind that, historically, the most significant upswing in recreational, sport hunting didn’t take place until the country was in an economical upswing, following WWII. There were a ton of factors at work, but not the least was that people had spare money and spare time.
The current economic trend is certainly ugly, but we’re still a very prosperous society. The bloat of the hunting and shooting sports industry is a testament to the fact that hunters still have plenty of spare money to spend on our sport… and apparently plenty of spare time to use all those new gadgets and gizmos. All this is good and fine now, but it sets the stage for a devastating collapse of the industry if Americans really have to start tightening their belts.
The prosperity and growth of the “industry” concerns me as well because of the upsurge in “pay-to-play” hunting opportunities. As guides and outfitters lease more property, and property owners recognize the financial incentive to charge tresspass fees, the opportunities for “free” hunting appear to be fading away. This may be simple perception versus reality, but that perception already has had a negative impact on the number of hunters. As folks find it harder to justify the cost of a hunt, that impact will worsen. The idea of hunting as a “rich man’s sport” may very well become the dominant reality.
As a whole, the hunting community is already hemorraghing members at a critical rate due to other factors besides the economy. A significant and prolonged economic downturn may very well be the telling blow to our sport, relegating us once and for all to fringe status… an unlikely coalition of the very wealthy and the hardcore.
I’ll still be there, one way or the other…
Posted on 24th September 2008
Under: General Observations and such | 12 Comments »




The slogan was, “I’d rather fight than switch.”
As we celebrate this anniversary of our nation’s independence, everyone should have a great time and do all those things that you do to recognize the importance and happiness of the occasion. At the same time though, let’s not get carried away to the point where you have to be carried away. 
